The Toning Premium Thread Part 2

I just popped a few sliders in the oven. LOL and I don't mean tiny burgers.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

What on earth?

I need to win one, I have a similar coin to post for comparison purposes

 

He said that this coin was at the top of the bag, under the tie, and a whole bunch of other jargin. Unless the guy, opened the bag? he could have, but I doubt it.

 

Okay, so that is what he meant by "bag knotted"...

 

Who else thinks he made that crap up?

 

Bag "NOT" !!! ....Hooey.

 

I'm sorry, but I don't believe that coin sold for $2,850. I've sold pedigreed MS64s with better toning for less than 1/4 that price.

 

I believe $2850 was the asking price, not necessarily the selling price.

 

Just like you, I don't think that coin sold for anywhere near that price. Maybe someone bought if for 1,000 (still a lot in my opinion) or the dealer just took it out of the case to make it look like their material was selling.

Personally, I've seen some ridiculous prices asked at shows. Now I sometimes put up items for sale at high prices too, but these dealers would put my prices to shame. And the funny thing is, when I offered many of them my strong toners for 1/3 (or even 1/4) of their prices, they all declined.

 

Based on the original post, you are correct. However, even the asking price seems crazy.

 

Let's see if we can handle two posts at the same time. Go ahead and post your example @IBetASilverDollar

@ddoomm1 can also post when they have time. This will be the official post and the @IBetASilverDollar post can be for points only but not posting privileges.

When referencing a price, make sure to identify whose coin it is (if more than one is listed).

 

Sounds good. Here's one I love that I picked up a few months back graded 63*. Normal 87 63's probably go for $60-$70. Have at it!

It may or may not be bag knotted, I'm not sure

 

180 for dollar

 

I'll say 215 for @IBetASilverDollar
...to me it looks like end roll toning...and I like this one, but will say that the previous Morgan was more appealing to me (but not a few thousand dollars more appealing)

Edit...forgot my own rule

 

I'll go $155 for @IBetASilverDollar

 

Yeah it's definitely end roll toning and definitely not as nice as the other one which has a killer look

 

$225

 

If I had to guess on the other one, I would also have called it end roll and not "bag knot"

 

$165 @IBetASilverDollar

 

$85