Just submitted these 3 coins to PCGS. The 1905 is an s/s. The 1851 has a nice die crack. Would it be a retained cud? I did not submit it as one, but might be able to get them to change that if it is. Any thoughts on grades, or if they will even grade? All are getting trueviewed and in doily holders. I am including my pictures, the seller's pictures, and the pictures from the auction he bought it from on the 1905-S. It's crazy how different it looks in all three pictures! I also have a submission of error gold coins that shipped to NGC the same day, so it will be interesting to compare grading times.
My thoughts are, you have some very awesome gold there dude. And I would love a bowl of Captain Crunch.
Grades finally popped today. Any guesses? True views are not showing up yet, but I will post when they do.
I'll go out on a limb and grade these... Above average. I can't seem to get within 10 points with these Indians/Libs, so I won't even try.
