eBay thee years ago. I spotted what I thought (and think) night be evidence of an overstrike. I think there is a K from (NEW YOR)K in the obverse field. When I received it, the weight indicated I was on to something. The 1795 NC-2s were both stuck on TAL Tokens so there is evidence some of them were used in Large Cent production as well as those cut down for Half Cent production. I just came across a 76 which is also underweight might also be a TAL Token, but it's less noticeable than this one. Would that make it 76c?
It can still be picked. I've cherried 3 raw ones over the past 5 years and had them certified and sold. An AG03, an AG details damaged, and an AU details heavily corroded.
Is there any chance it's actually clashed with the Eagle rather than the Double Eagle? The hair shape is right except the angle between the chin and the neck is more obtuse than the Double Eagle.