The Toning Premium Thread Part 2

@IBetASilverDollar you're up next!

You're welcome @Pickin and Grinin and feel free to keep on participating or watching. The thread has certainly had some interesting examples and hopefully more is to come.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'll pass it on to you, have a pretty busy day ahead of me

 

No worries...I will post this from a recent GTG.

PCGS AU 58 & CAC (green)
PCGS Guide price is $40

 

@heavycam.monstervam here it is...now let's see what everyone has to say.

 

Lets see - hmmmmmm
How about $80 ?

 

$175

 

$75

The toning is nice, but only on the reverse. If it was on the obverse, $100-125

 

$120

 

$126

 

Let's see some more participation @jtlee321 @SuperDave @baseball21 @Cascade @Kentucky @Volante @Johndoe2000$ @GDJMSP @oval_man
If anyone else posts, please try to tag someone you think might also want to give this thread a try.

 

I'd say maybe he got a steal at around $50

 

$95

 

If it talked to me in hand? I might go as high as 135

 

I'll say 4x guide on that, so $160. Not too often you see that neon orange color on a naturally toned coin.

 

Perhaps $100

 

I'll guess $100 since its reverse toning and missing the colors that get the crazy premiums for morgans usually

 

@Volante nailed it! The price was a few cents under $160. I would have certainly liked to pay less, but the competition was fierce and there was no chance this was going under 100 (in fact it reached 100 several days before bidding ended). It's likely the best AU Morgan I have seen and the eye appeal is on par with 64/65 graded pieces.

@Volante you're next.

 

Well given how horribly wrong I was on all of the previous coins, I guess I can just say that a broken clock's right twice a day!

Shifting to a different series, here's a 1946-S MS-65 Walking Liberty half dollar. Market price in this condition is about $90. Any guesses as to how much it sold for?

 

Fun thread idea!

I'll go with $120.

 

Love that walker! I'm going to guess $155