One-post wonder, and likely a sockpuppet for a certain other member who has an axe to grind against PCGS.
I wish that were true. He now owns two copper Pine Trees that the grading industry doesn't want him to get his 100 million dollars or so for https://www.cointalk.com/threads/ike-errors-on-ebay.299000/
I agree. It is an obviously AT coin, as the toning is very symmetrical, and in colors that are uncommon on Barbers. Just write it off for experience's sake. Sell it and don't worry about it. Unquestionably the work of a tone doctor.
Dang! I should check the dates because I know that this @USADealer is searching the forums, far and wide, for threads and posts that support his whiny position.
It was a 6 year old thread but it was a "new" thread last Thursday at post #16. So the posts from there, are relating to that and not the OP.
Oh gawd. A no-knowledge troll and the first thing he does is lay into Fred who just happens to finally join this group to share his considerable knowledge over here. I give him a day until he explodes and his account goes bye bye, who's taking the bets on this one guys??