Is there any possibility that you can give me any more reasoning on that then just say save your money I mean that's the reason I joined this chat room was to try to learn and then eventually maybe I'll be able to pass information on to other people not saying your wrong but there has been a few other people looked at it and said that it is so I'm just trying to get your opinion and why it's not and I'm okay either way with it thanks
The 1952 also looks more mechanical doubling - but my opinion is not worth much. The 2008 does look like a doubled ear from my googling and what pictures I found, but no clue if it is worth grading or not. My quick search did not show any for sale. Good luck no matter what you decide to do.
I can't speak for him, but I can tell you this. Many times even genuine variety or error coins are worth less than what it cost to slab them. So why spend $30-$40 to slab a coin that is only worth $10 ? Or less. Other times people will give an answer like that when they don't think the coin is a variety or error coin.