United States: 1915 copper-nickel 5-cents, Buffalo type PCGS MS63. Cert. #49268767. Numista-1109, Krause-Mishler-134. Mintage: 20,986,220. Ex-Don Rupp ("ajaan") on Collectors Universe; date of acquisition unrecorded (circa early 2020s). I acquired this in a multi-coin lot, as sort of an afterthought in a wider swap deal. At the time, I was without a Type 2 Buffalo nickel in my certified collection, so I adopted this piece as my type example. If one is doing a type set, then MS63 is a somewhat modest Mint State grade for a Buffalo nickel type coin, since coins with Gem grades of MS65 and higher are readily available, particularly for the later dates in the series. Despite that, this is a nice earlier date example and it has good eye appeal, so it will continue to serve as my type coin until I get around to upgrading it later. The price (in barter) was also reasonable. Don Rupp, the former owner, has been a coin trading partner of mine for a quarter of a century now. Coincidentally, he lives in Buffalo, New York, so you could say this Buffalo came from Buffalo. 015000
Strong strike. Beautiful tatanka nickel. Are the little vertical lines behind his cheekbone, right into the hairline, on the coin or slab? They may be what made this one top out at 63.
Considering that these pic are TrueViews, done pre-slab at PCGS, they must be on the coin. So maybe that’s it. Still looks pretty sharp for a 63, I reckon. Not that this series is one of my stronger suits, when it comes to grading them myself.