I got these 2 coins today for 65$ us. Do u think I got a good deal? What do u think they are worth? All comments are appreciated. Thx Also about the 1863 ihp there is a die crack on reverse, does that make it more valuable? If so how much? I believe the 1863 cent is xf-40. Let me know if u need better pics of the different areas of the coins.
The 1938D Buffalo is currently listed in Coin World at $50.00 in MS65. The 1863 is currently listed at $15-$23.00 in Fine or Very Fine. But the IHC looks to have been cleaned so this takes away some value. I don't think you got robbed but you did not make out much ahead of the game, IMHO. Nice die cracks though.
Take a closer look at the 38 D is the D a repunched mint mark? In 65 that would add value. Of a D/S again more value . Your images aren't clear enough to make a call here. As for the IHC you may wish to go to Indian head pennies.com and check if that die crack is a major marker.
Your 1863 reverse die crack maybe the CRK - 004 since you have the coin in hand check it out at the site I posted above.
I'm embarrassed, I don't yet know how to tag here, but yes, you can click on his screen name and start a conversation.