Yeah one of these are on the had to have list. This is how coins should be graded. Instead of not knowing what the "so called experts " are grading. No need for stickers..... You pay a fee and you get a coin graded with an explanation of what the coin grades and why.
Well, worst comes to worst, just say you picked up a penny off the street on the way home and it netted out to $49.99. The important point is, that sure don't look like no under-$50 IHC, not even a 1906.
I paid $28.95 for this fishy Morgan L. Marshall Civil War Token. The fishy was definitely worth it. I often wonder what qualified as "rare coin" in 1863...
Was out wandering with my wife, doing a bit of antique shopping and found this in a dealers display case for $25. All BU.
Here's a '40-S I picked up a couple of years ago. An obvious different obverse die but the die crack also bisects the coin. I'm pretty sure there's another obverse die with a different crack.