Canada 1949 5c

Discussion in 'Coin Chat' started by KBBPLL, Oct 16, 2025 at 12:30 AM.

  1. KBBPLL

    KBBPLL Well-Known Member

    No idea where this goes - world, error? nah, just a coin chat. I was browsing Canadian on GC and immediately saw the strong obverse die clash on this PCGS MS62. I needed to fill the nickel gap in my UNC George VI so I put in a bid. Won for $16 including BP and shipping. We love lots of pics on here, right?

    GC GreatPhoto - gotta love their effort on a coin with a book value of $8!
    1929089-3.jpg

    USPS was a fiasco but it arrived yesterday, more than two weeks after purchase.
    1949_5c_combo.jpg

    These are sometimes generically called Hearing Aid varieties for the clash inside the ear.
    1949_5c_clash.jpg

    I've seen them listed for nickels and dollars in various years, so they're not that uncommon. The dies took a serious whacking this time though. The two images above highlight different die cracks on the reverse, and in hand I detect some subsistence of parts of that die. I'm thinking it didn't last long afterwards. The crack at 2:00 goes through the maple leaf and then out to the rim.

    The overlay on Maddieclashes is quite busy and not aligned properly, so I reversed the reverse and put in some arrows to show where the obverse clashing came from.

    1929089-3_edit3.jpg

    There's more. The rump of the beaver is clashed in front of old George and I'm not sure what's at the back of his head (see second image). It must be part of the maple leaf.

    Here I'm trying a different angle. The beaver butt clash in front of George is hard to capture. The reverse shows another clash under the beaver's nose of the back of George's neck and another crack at the C of Cents, not seen in the other pics. I'm surprised there isn't more clash on the reverse considering how broken the die is from it.

    IMG_3562_zoom_combo.jpg

    I found another one from the same die pair and about the same die state that sold on ebay in August for $CAD40 (about $USD25, seller's pics).

    1949_5c_ebay_combo.jpg

    Shout out to @BoneDust who posted a similar thread about a 1948 12 years ago and is still actively watching the forum! https://www.cointalk.com/threads/1948-canada-5-cents-multiple-die-clashes.238425/

    I got my $16 worth and then some.
     
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. SensibleSal66

    SensibleSal66 U.S Casual Collector / Error Collector

    Nice purchases and finds! What do they call this Clash again? Never listened to the band by the way.:smuggrin:
    I can come up with a few names. :oops::sorry:
     
  4. ksmooter61

    ksmooter61 Scary ghost - BOO!

    Excellent research. It was difficult to see where the clashes around the ear came from but your details show it. That must have been a crazy clash to have the transfer from the recessed part of the hammer onto the recessed part of the anvil not only occur but be so visible. Perhaps the die was fully broken but still retained?
     
    KBBPLL likes this.
  5. Bill in Burl

    Bill in Burl Collector

    sometimes, people with some skill will superimpose the Rev over the Obv and you can see even tiny sparks!
     
  6. KBBPLL

    KBBPLL Well-Known Member

    It took me a while to figure out that the triangle inside the ear is the rear of the beaver's front paw. I suppose the inner ear is fairly shallow on the die, but the clash all the way across George's neck is pretty crazy.

    I think I figured out that the one behind his head came from the sharpest edge of the maple leaf. I love analyzing a coin to death. :)
    1929089-3_edit4.jpg
     
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page