Not all that familiar with this series but I thought this one looked ok. XF meat on it looks like and maybe some cuds on reverse rim?
Um... how sure are we that it's legit? I don't know if that kind of rim action is common on these, but I see some places where the design seems to be sinking into the fields, and I'm not sure how sharp the letters are supposed to be...?
I'd put this at a mid-VF. Not enough detail, and no luster... can't make EF-40 in my interpretation of those pictures. I think some of those reverse rim effects may be small cuds... but I'm also seeing quite a few rim bruises. Especially on the obverse, those rim dings will absolutely bring down the value but may also bring down the grade. Given the amount of rim damage on the obverse, it is really hard to tell what on the reverse might be a tiny, inconsequential cud and which might actually be more rim damage.
