I've checked this against all of the Newcomb listings and cannot find an exact match. This sure looks like a repunched or overdate variety as it doesn't look like MD, but the wear could be affecting it? Just asking for some input as to what exactly I have here. I know she's a little rough, but still a decent coin.
Give me one second. Edit: My first impression is that it is N-1, that variety is known to have strong repunching in the earlier die states. I will have to double check in my books when I get home.
After looking at the reverse a bit closer, I think you nailed it. I was too focused on the date and neglected any other markers like the ones around the inner denticles on the reverse.
