1909s Lincoln Green Spots Clean?

You're not finished with this, and I'll bet you are going to surprise us with the results.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Quick story. I once owned an 1864-L Indian cent that was badly corroded. Without all the corrosion, the cent was in a high grade, maybe XF or so. I decided at some point to see if I could take off the corrosion, and it didn't take long to get it off. Unfortunately, the corrosion had completely engulfed the "L" on the ribbon, so when I got rid of the corrosion, I also got rid of the "L." Of course, it still had a pointed bust, so it was obviously the variety with the designer's initial. Be glad your 1909-S didn't lose its mintmark in the cleaning!

 

By the way, I do think your coin looks better without all the green on it. However, it's still a dog, IMO.

 

I did try one last thing and I think that will probably be it for this coin. Thanks to everyone for your suggestions and comments. Just the before and after photos.

 

It absolutely looks a lot better. I think stopping is a good idea, anymore conservation would probably cause metal loss/ fatigue.
I don't think it will grade. But could bring a good price on EBAY.

 

.....as I predicted.

 

So, "Karnak" we all could see the pitting on the original green coin.

IMO the real question is this: I'm curious if you and others here think the OP improved the coin's eye appeal or not? I for one am very pleased with his results. He may have (?) even used your product.

 

If someone offered me the original coin or the "new improved" version as a gift, I would choose the "new improved" version. Additionally if it has VerdiCared, hopefully it has some protection for the future.

 

I would use Brighto - it makes old bodies new