This is a nice coin, but I see absolutely no luster, you would think it would have some to achieve a 53 with the apparent scratches and gauges going of the face maybe some details to boot ! no winner on this one, will post another soon.
This one gets "the opposite of CAC award." Sorry, but giving that coin an AU-53 is ridiculous. The marks on the face would have had me figuring on a "details" grade when I submitted it. One does get $3 gold coins graded, however, because of the counterfeit problems that have plagued these coins since I started collecting in the 1960s. This one must be an MS-67. It's actually an MS-63. As a follow-up, this 1854-D, which is well known for weak strikes, is graded AU-55, CA