Same here. I'm not unhappy with mine, bit I don't think I had the proper experience to collect a set at the time I did.
thanks the buffalo nickel has always been my favorite coin I never tried to get a set of them until the past few years.
i never had much luck with old anacs holders. I had a 1859 indian cent go from ms63 to ms64 with PCGS and a ms65 buffalo go to ms66 with NGC.