GTG of these PCGS Quarters

This is not a contest. I would just like an honest opinion of these two PCGS graded quarters. One (A) is a 1946-D and the other (B) is a 1945-S Quarter. Hoping that the pictures are good enough for your evaluation. Thanks much,

Dave

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

nice set i have a roll still in the sleeve.

 

I'll go 64 & 66 (assuming the marks are on the holder & not coin #2s reverse)
Don't you trust the almighty PCGS ? (Blasphemy!!!!)

 

66
65

 

'64
'65

Based on pics.

 

64
64

 

Thanks guys. Heavycam asked if I did not trust PCGS. Will, this is why I posted this item. Both quarters were graded MS65 by PCGS. It was my opinion as some of you noted that the 1946-D quarter looks to be a MS64. In any case, I have been thinking of returning the 64 to Heritage as not acceptable. What do you think ?

Dave

 

I think Heritage will be really ticked at you if you ask to return the coin.

 

I think you might be right Larry. After all it's not their fault how PCGS grades the coins.

 

The return issues for Heritage aside, I wouldn't put much weight into it. Grading from pictures is hard enough with the best of images and those images are a bit lacking for coming to a hard conclusion on the grade. Washington's are a hard series to grade as well. That quarter may not be the greatest for the grade and some may disagree even after seeing it in hand, but I wouldn't definitely say it was from this thread.

That said if you don't really like it sell it and get one you do.

 

"That said if you don't really like it sell it and get one you do".

Baseball, I may have overpayed for this coin ($21.00) because I was bidding on a 1964-D MS65. If the coin is not MS65, I hardly think I could get my original money back by a resale.

Dave