Since the scale appears to be accurate it is either copper (unlikely due to the silver color on the reverse) or a copper plated zinc struck on an over weight planchet. The next step (without spending a bunch of money sending it in) would be a specific gravity test. That would tell you for sure. A copper cent would have a SG of 8.83 and a plated zinc of 7.17
What is a gravity test and how would I do that? Also, would I be able to send it to CONECA and let them do a test?
As others have indicated, this cent was struck on a planchet punched out of zinc stock that was rolled too thick. It doesn't appear that the plating was excessively thick (the other possible cause of an overweight zinc cent).
I do believe it is zinc because it sounds different than a copper coin when dropped on a wooden table.
I had it looked at at a coin store and he couldn't explain it either. His only guess was that maybe it had a foreign material in it. He suggested I send it to CONECA.
Depends on the height and whether you mean the sound he makes on the way down or the one when he hits.