May be the pics but luster seems a bit subdued and it looks like it might have light wear. Think I'd have go with 58 based on what I can see.
The middle band is the key diagnostic on these, @mac266, and it doesn't have it. I think it's over-dipped, too, which explains its rather motionless "luster." If it's EF40, I'll say it just slid in under the tag.
Yeah, I realized that after I posted. My eye goes straight to the 2 first on every 42 merc I see and I jumped the shark. Same with the last T of trust on every 1919 now. The eye goes straight to it almost by reflex
You need better lighting. The first coin would be a good one to advertise head wings, but why is the wearer afraid to show her face
It would be better if the lighting was uniform and not coming from 3 o'clock. On the first photo of the Obv, the face is incognito.