It's a nice group of coins and you certainly could have paid more money for them than you did. But, I agree with GDJMSP that you could have paid a little less as well. I would have probably paid between $150 and $175 for the group. Certainly enjoy them, they look very nice.
I bought a couple more really nice coins 1883 P PCGS MS 62 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR OLD GREEN HOLDER 1943 P NGC MS 66 LINCOLN STEEL CENT
He probably did alright for $200. Reality in todays coin market says NGC and PCGS slabs WILL have a premium.....