Greek Alexander III

I posted pictures below and am asking if this coin is real? I found it in a glass cigar tube filled with Liberty Dimes. I labeled the coin as to what I think it is. Thanks for any help.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Can you remove it from the flip and take a picture of it, rather than a scan? Scans always make silver coins look suspect. A higher-resolution pic would be good, like around a 1000 pixels wide.

 

I'll give it a try

 

Here is my try

 

Can you post the diameter in mm and the weight in grams please? Don't hold your breath on this one methinks.

 

I'm new to ancient coins, but I vote fake. Too round, and the way the light glints off the edge in the obverse image makes it look as if the edge has been mechanically filed. Patina also looks painted or applied. And all of that aside, there is just something about it which screams out "tourist coin" to me.

 

Looks fake to me too.

 

Here are the cropped and joined images from the thread you posted this in four days ago. As requested then, larger images might be helpful-- but perhaps not, since it seems to be fake based on the information presented so far. Weight on the 2x2 is stated as 4.3 gm.



Not many people weighed in, but I did post a link to what appears to be a match in a fakes database.

 

Man, I love "The Riverside Hotel" paper ... it gives it even less of an authentic chance (I want to circle "dream") ...




... but I'm a bad vote => for I always like the look of fakes (they usually choose really nice coins)

=> Hey, I always want ancient coins to be proven "authentic" ... I hope that this baby runs the gauntlet and proves to be a total stallion!!

=> good luck, capthank

 

4.0 to 4.1 grams and 3.048mm

 

Thanks a lot for the info and better picture

 

Disclaimer: I'm not overly knowledgeable about Greek coins, although I've viewed many of them both online and in catalogs.

When looking at the obverse of this coin, the regularity and consistent striking of the ring of raised dots surrounding the portrait looked extremely suspicious. I did a search on ACSEARCH of this coin and got 150 matches, of which about half are this type. Not a single one had an obverse as well centered, nor were there any with all the raised dots visible and well struck. Based on that comparison alone, I can't imagine that this coin is genuine.

I voted fake.

 

*rats*

Hey don't give up hope quite yet ... maybe somebody else will send you a Hail-Mary and prove it to be the Holy Grail?

 

Real or Fake it was a fun find and has me starting to learn about coins. Hey, I knew it wasn't a Dime!

 

Exciting though, eh?

Hey cap, maybe you should spend $20 and buy a real ancient coin ... yah, they can be that inexpensive (amazing, eh?)

=> here is a link to your possible next ATG ancient coin ...

https://www.vcoins.com/en/Search.aspx?search=true&searchQuery=alexander the great &searchQueryExclude=&searchCategory=0&searchCategoryLevel=2&searchCategoryAncient=True&searchCategoryUs=False&searchCategoryWorld=False&searchCategoryMedieval=False&searchBetween=0&searchBetweenAnd=0&searchDate=&searchUseThesaurus=True&searchDisplayCurrency=&searchDisplayAsList=False&searchIdStore=0&searchQueryAnyWords=&searchExactPhrase=&searchTitleAndDescription=True&searchDateType=0&searchMaxRecords=100&SearchOnSale=False&Unassigned=False

... capthank, I hope you search that link and find a sweet example in your price-range (warning though, for these ancient coins are very addictive)

 

If that is an ancient coin, then I have another ancient coin to sell you. Ignore what appears to be an 1858 date on it, that's really cuneiform for "This coin is really ancient...honestly!"





* Sorry guys, I couldn't resist. I really love this coin and wanted to share something from the lighter side of coin collecting...ie. slabbed Americans. Please don't ban me for this abomination.

 

Slabbed Americans?!! ... you can buy 'em already slabbed?!!

You mean I've been wasting all of this time collecting ancient coins when I could have been collecting coins from a few years ago at extremely high prices!!?



... just jokes, Sallent (I also have previous non-ancient coin-collecting avenues) ... but they all seem so long ago now, eh? (once bitten by the dark-side, you seem to never look back)

 

It is all a matter of supply and demand. Millions of people like those eagles. I even wanted the type and bought one when it wasn't even a hundred years old yet and you could get culls for a dollar. Your coin is better but mine was easier to photograph.


Many fewer want ancients. This hobby was cheaper for me before Steve found out about it and started paying all those Canadian nickels for ancients. Now he wants to tell another generation our best kept secret. Hush!

I started collecting ancients because my sensibility prevented me paying more than a nickel for a nickel even if it had a buffalo on it. It did not seem so bad paying $2 for a denarius.

 

That's the truth!

 

I have a confession to make! I do collect a few moderns!!
I tend to collect coins and bank notes from Communist countries, I find the iconography on them to be fascinating.

RUSSIA, SOVIET (USSR). 1924. 50 KOPEKS. VF.
Russia, Soviet (USSR). 1924. 50 Kopeks (26 mm, 9.92 g).