1936-S Oregon Trail Commemorative Half - grade opinions

I picked up a raw Oregon Trail Comm today at the coin show. This baby has great eye appeal and blistering white luster. I'd like to get your opinion on grade. Thanks in advance.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'd say a 64 , luster really carries these . Even one with minimal hits will grade lower because of muted luster . Nice coin though .

 

Heck, it wouldn't surprise me if it went -65 or -66.

 

I say ms 65 nice pick up I like it

 

Could go '65 or higher......

 

I'd say 65 or possibly 66 on a good day. Really nice coin, and I haven't see that many for sale in that condition.

Andrew

 

I'm at MS67. It is very much like the one I had except that mine was toned.

Chris

 

This is 100% true. I'd say the photo justifies a 65, but, given my misstep with his MS66 Buffalo nickel, I'd say this photo probably doesn't show the full amount of luster. I'd say minimum MS66, shot at 67.

 

I always love that design .. At a glance, 64-65 depending on luster

 

I love these coins! Great pickup!

 

65 - mark on the abs and the chatter on the right leg keep it from going higher. Just my opinion.