Thanks everybody for contributing to this informative post. I just picked up this CWT in a mixed bag of 'junk'. Can someone help me attribute this Yankee Robinson token? OH? IL? Fuld #? Specs: 3.3 grams; reeded edge; when rotated <----> the finger points at 8:00 and 'BIG SHOW' is at 6:00-8:00.
The Indian head is die 1046, and the only other 1864 dated die used for Yankee Robinson tokens is die 1047. The old number for the token itself is OH 165EZ-12a, listed as Rarity 6. I don't bother with the new numbers partly because they will be changing, the later-dated tokens will be separated from the Civil War dated tokens next time.