Which Coin Do You Like Better??

Which 1885o Morgan dollar is better and should be used as the 1885o Morgan dollar in my Morgan dollar set. I'm keeping both of them, I just want to know which is better for the set. Also, Which 1885o would be more valuable and grade higher if I sent it in (Yes, I'm thinking about sending one in)??

I have the very lustrous one I got yesterday, the problem is there are quite a few contact marks.

(Yes I screwed up editing the photo)


Now you got the other 1885o Morgan. Very nice luster but less frosted reflective as the other one. Not nearly as many contact marks either.




What do you think?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I prefer the frosty coin

 

I like the "18850" better due to the nicks on the other coins obverse and big nick on the reverse. Probably would grade a point higher too.

 

which 1885, the top on or bottom. I think you mean the bottom though. What will the bottom grade?

 

The one that has "18850" written on the holder. (bottom one)
The bottom one probably won't get a 65 but is a pretty good 64

 

I vote for the "black ink" 85-O. I would take a guess and say a 64 for the grade on that coin.

 

I'll choose one of the 7 obverses and one of the 3 reverses.

Chris