I think I would go with X! I need photos, just telling me "is this real" with no real info let alone one single photo, would make it impossible to make a real decision.
I tried to load large photos but could not? here is the link.1885 Liberty Head Nickel MS+++ ERROR DOUBLE STR 1885 Liberty Head Nickel MS+++ ERROR DOUBLE STRUCK ebay
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1885-Libert...05?pt=Coins_US_Individual&hash=item4ae3817f71 Are you talking about this one?
That's wrong on so many counts: The rim is entirely wrong -- where are the denticles on the "overstruck" part? The stars look like Christmas cookies. I see blobs of metal on top of devices. The surfaces look grainy. What else am I missing?
Go to your photo program and resize the image if you can. If it does not look right then you will have to get closer images.
I hope the seller takes it down before someone buys it not knowing it is 100% fake, the date and stars are a giveaway, plus being a huge error on a BU key date coin is very unlikely.