GTG - IHC x3

Guess the grades, give me your first impression. Results tomorrow.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I love the second toned one. Super cool. I have a 1903 one that is toned almost exactly like the third one. I'm not sure if that's because of past cleaning or not.

 

1. 63 O / 62 R --- 62

2. 63 or 64 O / 64 R --- 64

3. 64 O / 64 or 65 R --- 64

 

58 bn 64 bn 62 r&b I love the second!!

 

55/58
Unc details - questionable color (if it grades - 64)
63

 

AU-58
AU-58
AU-55

The discoloration on the high points looks like rub to me. Now, the TPGs and I disagree on this point - so I wouldn't be surprised to see any of these in anything up to 63 holders.

 

All the same coin? 63BN.

 

Same coin shot with three types of lighting or angles of lights.

 

Not the same coin. If nothing else, the date is in 3 different positions. Really!

 

And the results...

PCGS MS63 BN


PCGS MS62 BN (??????!!!! )


PCGS MS65 BN


This is the third example of an MS62 they've given me, and I really disagree with the results. I'm letting my PCGS membership expire. If I decide to go with another membership, it will be NGC. Or I'll tag onto someone else's.

 

Whose pics? PCGS or yours?

 

PCGS

 

I don't get any the first I'd say au 58 a 62 max the third has a ding right below the jaw is say keep it in the 63 category the middle the best in my opinion a solid 64 ngc more consistent in my opinion and far better with copper

 

Btw the third (ms 65) is pcgs coinfacts plate coin for 1891

 

I was going to say 45-55-62 so I guess, as usual, I have no idea what I'm talking about.