Grade this Standing Liberty Quarter

What would you grade it?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

55

 

Might be 58, might be MS, definitely full head -- but I'm not sure TPGs would buy the color.

 

I'm going with KoinJester 55

 

MS-60

 

AU-58 . Not sure about the color .

 

AU58 FH. Personally, I like the toning.

 

Au-58 full head

 

I'm at 53 or 55. Nice coin.

 

AU58 FH.....don't know about the color though, I would go PCGS on it as opposed to NGC.

 

Looks AU58FH to me. I don't see any problems with the toning, and it's a very attractive example of the design/type.

 

Did it come out of a PCGS holder? It's AU58

 

Not sure.

 

AU58 seems to be the consensus. But where is the wear? I am not seeing a flat knee,a wear mark on the breast or wear on the wing.

 

I'm seeing, or imagining, a bit on the knee, the high points of the hair (although that could be just a toning effect), and maybe the leading edge of the wing. Hard to tell from a single still photo, though -- that's why I said "maybe MS".

 

I can't spot any wear on my AU58FH SLQ either, but I thought "wear" should be minimal on an AU58 coin by definition.

 

I'm thinking AU58 due to the wear (I think) on the leading edge of the wing. Can't judge luster and highpoint wear easily from photos. If the obverse photo shows the actual color of the coin, I'm not sure it would pass muster at a TPG service, although it appears attractive. my 2 cts.

 

It's AU and I don't think the color is original, either.

 

What makes you think the color isn't original?

 

Experience.