Guess the grade, Morgan Dollar....

This is not my coin:

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

MS68

 

It's hard to see how clean the fields are as the coin does appear to have a little haze to it. I'm not sure if the marks I see are haze or dings. I'm inclined to say they are haze. Due to this being an 1880-S...which is one of the finest preserved and best struck dates...I know the TPGs are extra harsh here. Other dates, I could see this coin in the 68+ range...but I'm going to say MS67 on this one.

 

67-68 for sure. With the lack of any real distracting marks and it being semi-PL i'm leaning toward 68.

 

My guess is MS66+ although I can see a TPG grading it MS67 or even MS67+.

 

My first impression of the obverse was MS68, but I think the reverse fields are going to bring it down to MS67.

 

63pl

 

One more day and will post the slab. My friend owns this coin, and is selling it.

 

I will go with 67.

 

MS65

 

I went MS68. Looks to have some PL as well. Agree with Lehigh about the reverse bringing the grade down, but I left it at 68.

 

If graded by Doug, it's an MS63....maybe.

 

I thought he was the AU vote, due to the "cloudy" area that Ritchie mentioned--he thought that to be "wear."

 

I do see one person voted details.. I'm guessing that's his vote. I think we need a new "guess" poll thread, and we can all guess what HE grades a coin, not what it really is.

 

68

 

Is this thread about a coin or about making fun of Doug? Not cool.

 

Liberty's face looks like it was wiped.

 

Here is the coin. No, the thread is a "guess the grade" thread. My friend's coin. Population 165. Only 5 at MS 69.

 

I thought the chatter on her neck and the hits on the reverse would've brought down the grade. Although, I have seen many worse 68s.