1877 Proof Trade Dollar Does it CAC???

Hey guys!

This coin walked into the shop today. I'm going to send it to CAC. Do you think it gets the blessing?
Make sure to note that while this coin does have some hair lining... all of the major lines that show up on the reverse are on the holder.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Tom would probably be the best person to ask since he's pretty familiar with CAC.

Chris

 

Looks to have some color in the fields.

I going with the gold bean

 

sure!

 

I believe it will, but I must admit, even when I've been sure a coin would CAC in the past, it has not passed. Either way, it's a $12.50 risk, so why wouldn't you take it? I know I would.

 

Grading a classic proof from one set of images shot through plastic? I will guess, note "guess", that it will receive a sticker.

 

100% cac-age.

 

Yeah, I thought about a reholder... but I do like the OGH...

 

I think it will get a sticker. Eve though there is some hair-lining...it looks pretty clean for a PF62. So, I'll say it stickers.

 

My vote yes a beautiful coin!!

 

Stop it, Matt. You're making me cry.

 

My guess is yes as that's one pretty 62 even nicer than some 63 Proofs I've looked at . One Green bean coming up .

 

Made me drool and reach for my checkbook!

 

Matt could they reholder it and use the OGH ? I know the slabs wouldn't match but the label should fit .

 

Yes.

 

I don't see why they couldn't but would they?

 

Yes but , some of those deeper scratches don't come out , and that coin deserves a good holder . Nothing worse than looking at a great coin with a bad slab .