I never buy these, but while at the shop I did a quick eBay completed auctions search and thought I was doing pretty good on them. I paid $775 for the pair, so maybe I did ok? Here are mine:
Those are beautiful. I would definitely pay far more than $775 for the pair any day. I think you did very well.
There's a good possibility that both of these would get upgraded to MS-63 if resubmitted. I believe that both would get at least a green and possibly a gold sticker from CAC. Very nice pair of quarters.
I think they look awful in circulated condition. Something about the wear is just EXTREMELY unattractive to me. But in BU, they are sweet for sure.