I do not want to sell this coin and I am worried about giving it to a dealer to send in as I have no relationship with any dealers. What would be the best way to store it till I do get it slabbed?
That coin could easily get AU. These weren't the best of dies and were overused and graders tend to allow for that. Good luck!
I'd put it at a VF35. worth getting graded if you're selling it. It will bring a much bigger premium as the buyer would be a lot more confident!