The coin in question is very close to #2, but I am pretty sure is not #2. Therefore, it is counterfeit.
If I understand this correctly there are only 5 dies that squashed 1193000 planchets - so average die life was over 200K. Is that par for the course then? how has that changed with time?
Yes, close to the 2 but definitely not a match. The edge lettering on the coin doesn't appear to have any wear at all. I'd say it's most likely a fake!
I don't like the "fatness" to the bottom of the MM. Also, the serifs don't look right to me, and the overall weakness of it. I don't know if it's fake. I just wouldn't buy it.
Looks completely counterfeit and very poorly artificially aged. To me the most glaring mistake that counterfeiters make is that they are always void of contact marks of any kind. How many times do you find a coin in your change that has no marks on it at all?
I actually purposely got one of the fakes as a filler. And I have to say it looks like the same coin just with some dirt thrown on it.
I dug out my 1914-D that I have had for 52 years. Sorry I can't get a closer pic of the "D" like the good ones "rlm's cents" posted.
The "D" is the same identical "D" on all 5 dies. They used the same punch for that "D" on all coins from that era. I don't remember the specific dates, but like 1911 through 1920's. My picture show the exact location of that "D" on the 5 master dies used to produce all 1914-D Lincolns. As for your coin, the pictures are just too small for me to tell for sure.
Bumping this with another fake. Just bc I want to keep anyone here from getting burned. 1857 flying eagle And a link i found of a guy in china pressing his own fakes. 10 1914-D Unc - $9.00
Are you guys saying the coin AND the slab is fake, or just the coin? edit: I think maybe the original ebay link is dead, and its now redirecting to other similar searches? Very confusing for people trying to read back through some old posts.