Although melt is $1.22 they are not worth $1.22. Since they are only 35% silver they are less desirable than 90% or .999 silver. War nickels usually trade at least 20% less than silver value. 25 cents is not a fair offer.
Yeah, I would definitely recommend counting them, taking an in-focus picture of your war nickels as a group, and posting them here in the For Sale section, or on eBay. No fees here, though... Coin shops and pawn shops are generally going to be a weak buyer of war nickels unless they are relatively better grade.