Bought a 1948 Franklin half, got a 1948-D

From eBay. One "guide" on the Web says that the 1958 is worth more, another says the opposite.

Granted, it's just a dollar difference... Should I be happy or sad?

Thanks.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

It completely depends on the condition of the half.

 

Got a pic of it?

 

I wouldn't worry about it, unless it's a high-grade. I'd still leave neutral feedback, though.

 

Here are pics.

 

I'd change the thread title. Same goes for the '48.

 

Dang. How do I edit the original post? Thanks. Wasn't at home and had my wires crossed (in my brain).

 

Well, in that grade it doesn't much matter if it's a '48 P, D or '58 P,D....

 

Really? Why would you do that?
What's your ebay username, so I can ban you?

Did the seller refuse to remedy the issue?
Was the seller even contacted?
Was the coin in the image 58 or the 58 D?

Mistakes are made and sometimes the wrong coin gets sent out.
How does that deserve a neutral or negative feedback?

If the seller doesn't do what they can to fix the problem, then there is a reason.