My personal opinion is it would be worth about whats on the 2x2 IF those scratches weren't on the reverse. In current condition probably around several dollars.
Tim is pretty close with his guess... here's a similar coin with scratched reverse that sold for $10.49 on the 'Bay: http://www.ebay.com/itm/VF-1857-FLYING-EAGLE-PENNY-NO-RESERVE-SCRATCHED-REVERSE-/360684766179?
I still need one for my type set . Too bad about those scratches though . A word of advice , it's always better to pay a little extra and get a problem free coin . In case you want to upgrade they'll always be easier to sell . I know sometimes it's hard to save the extra money , but it's well worth it in the end . I do like the obverse though , and if you're happy then that's all that matters .
