1921 S Morgans, 1922/3 S Peace, 1924/6 S Buffalo Nickels I could really use some help determining the value on these: 4x 1921 S Morgan 1922 S Peace 1923 S Peace 1924 S Buffalo Nickel 1926 S Buffalo Nickel
Most all buffalos 1927 and later are not worth much, my local shop sells them for .25 each. If you cant read the date I would guess they are worth much less. Morgans & Peace dollars are very common. Many Millions of them never left the mint until the 60s-70s so finding them in BU condition is common. My local guy sells them for silver value, $18 today, but I have seen people ask 25-30 with no luck selling them.
I wasn't talking about 1927 and later Buffalos. I'm talking about 2 key dates with low mintage. The '24 date is readable, though the scan did it no justice. The '21 s Morgans sell for around $6000 authenticated in mint. The 3 peace dollars are also key dates. Now I know what I have isn't worth mint prices, but I also know they're worth a good bit more than melt value. I think I'll hold out for the opinion of a collector vs that of a silver buyer. Thanks though.
Can't speak for the Buffalos but sorry to say, you're Morgan's aren't worth much more that melt prices. They seem to go for a premium on eBay for around $30 a piece. The 21 S is worth $6000 in very high BU condition. Yours is no where near that condition and is worth the same as any other common morgan in that condition. Same for the Peace dollars. Those are pretty common dates and in their condition worth the same as every other common Peace dollar .
Wow, I have been collecting for 15 years and thats the first time I have seen someone ask for help then respond like that. Needless to say your coins arent worth much more than melt. You need to spend some more time in the real world and get your nose out of that price guide. You may be grossly misinterpreting "key date". People are so crazy about morgans, yet they dont read history. Many millions of morgans sat in the mint until the 60s-70s and they are very common. Im not sure where this guy sees a 1921 S is $6000, but if thats the case I have rolls of them to sell to anyone looking to spend $6000 each. In my price guide they are $18-19 each and $24 uncirculated. The nerve of the uneducated continuously surprises me.
