Hi all, I am new here, and new to collecting coins. I've basically starting coin collection on a amauter level to have something to hand down to our kids. Anyway, I (blindly) bought some coins online in a grab bag type of auction- before I start regretting that decision- I wondered if anyone could tell me if these coins are truly what they say they are and/or worth the price that is written on the holder. I know it's difficult to advise without seeing them in person, so here are some photos. Hopefully someone can shed some light on these coins. 1st coin- 1934 Buffalo, (DBL DIE REV, fs-05-803). $25 2nd coin- 1901 penny, (repunched date, RPD-019). $22 3rd coin- 1964 Quarter, (highgrade, DBL DIE ORV). $90 Thanking all in advance! Joe
Okay in order: 1,2 & 3: all overpriced, by a lot. 1) Not the usual DDO, and I see nothing here, obv or rev. 2) The Indian may be a RPD, but minor added valuue, generally, with exceptions; 3) I see nothing except for possible strike doubling on the obv. No added value
ahhh, ok, this is good to hear. I appreciate feedback. They are all being returned tomorrow morning!!
you can return them! Lucky, and the quarter has a nasty fingerprint that dramatically affects the value.
I am an amateur collector too I suggest getting a coin price guide to start of with. (if you havent done so already) and dont get into varieties, just start collecting dates. A coin folder might help.
Yeah, I do not know what made me bid on this lot- beginners mistakes, I guess. I regretted it almost right away- now I know better for future purchases. And yes, I can return...hopefully that goes through smoothly. I think I'll take my business to the more legit local coin shop and APMEX, etc. Will definitely get the price guide, too. Much appreciated guys! Joe
Your photos are not of the quality necessary to give an opinion on the claimed varieties, which are not something the novice should be buying raw, at least when from an unknown source. I am not aware of an 1934-D 5C with an FS#, at least as of the 5th edition. In this condition, I doubt the 1901 IHC is worth anywhere near the written price. I cannot think of any RPDs for this date that would have much value in this grade. I quickly checked CONECA and there are eight DDOs for this date/mint, so the generic label means nothing, and this is even if it is an actual doubled die. That said, the chances of this coin being a variety worth $90 in this condition is slim to none. If you are looking for coins to share with your children, I suggest you start with the basics and learn while building a hobby together. Many people, who have had only the best of intentions, have thrown good money away on junk because they did not take the time to educate themselves and/or blindly trusted the person they bought from. If you wish to continue with this hobby, take your time and try to find a knowledgeable and respected dealer in your area willing to assist you. When collecting with children, always remember that the greatest value can be in the time spent together as a family.
