What I have said is that if you store coins properly that you won't likely be able to see a change in toning in your lifetime. But that doesn't mean the toning never actually changed. It just means that the changes were subtle enough that you likely wouldn't be able to notice the change. As long as air can get to the coin, any air, the coin is toning. But it is at a very slow pace if stored properly.
if you really want to harvey can tone the coin any color you want within 24 hours while still in the slab. the us mint itself supplies matierials that aid in toning oh we live in such a beautiful world only one problem i hate toning
depends on the air grandpa. some air will make it tone faster than anything you have ever seen you should really quantify what a life time means
Off the top of my head: Gasses in the air (sulfur, methane, etc). Humidity Quick changes in temperature from cold to hot, and vice versa.
So if I were to walk in and out of my house in the winter with a coin, it would tone? That seems unlikely.
There is a well known book called Coin Chemistry by Weimar White. I don’t own the book but I have read a friend’s copy. (It was a short read as I recall). I believe that there is an example provided in the book where a coin is toned inside its slab. Sorry, I don’t have the book to confirm this. Perhaps someone with the book would chime-in. BTW, most slabs are not air tight. Also, I believe that there have been slabs that included materials inside the slab that caused toning affects. I give no fault to the slab companies that used the materials because they were just as surprised as the coin owners.
I know air causes coins to tone further, but how come the most rarest coins are not store under vacuum?
Dry air, with no sulfur source, has very, very, nearly zero ability to tone a coin. Storing under a vacuum is troublesome in its own right, so the best/cheapest way to store good coins is in a holder mostly air tight, with dry clean air around it. Also, keep it out of any light source.
It isn't unlikely at all, depending on how long you stay outside of course. Stay in or out long enough for the temperature of the coin to change, and I can almost guarantee it's going tone. The going from hot to cold or vice versa is going to cause condensation on the coin, and that moisture will make it tone.
Sounds like a fun experiment. Not trying to increase the coin in value, could I put a silver roosie in my pocket and go around as usual? It's around 70 degrees indoors and 35 degrees outdoors. Would this cause a noticable tone, and would it be NT or AT?
Regardless of the level of protection, all coins will keep toning over their lives. It's all a matter of rate.
Isn't that just a bit 'bulky'? Like, I can see the lady askin' me, 'is that a gun in your pocket or are you just happy to see me'?...........