Need some advice ASAP. My dad is letting me have one of his Morgans. Which to take?

Ok I have to do this quick. Ill throw up some pics if you guys could tell me what looks best and the associated value
First: 1884-O


Pics of the others coming momentarily

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Um......you posted two different obverse photos, but the reverse photos are the same. Note the gouge between the right-hand wreath and the eagle's left wing.

Chris

 

I think it is the same coin, 2 pics of both obv and rev... maybe MS-64

 

Option 2: 1924-P Peace Dollar

 

option 1

 

Option #1 hands down. TC

 

1897-s

 

I would definitely pick #1

 

And lastly an 84-CC, with a fairly nice looking reverse and a Obverse that has that trademark "Mike Tyson sparring partner" look..... so what would you do?

 

I change to option 4

 

The CC

 

CC easily. You know there will always be a demand for that mm. That 97-S don't look bad either!

 

Yessir you are correct, 2 pics of each. I wanted to take the second pic to show how the Obverse looks with light coming in at a different angle... it makes the slight abrasion in the field to the left of her mouth and to the right of the M in UNUM appear much better. Any ideas what it may be worth if it happens to to be MS-64?

 

http://www.numismedia.com/fmv/prices/mordlr/pricesgd.shtml

This would be usefull for an idea about how they compare in price

 

CC hands down.

 

See that is exactly where I am having problems. I know the CC can be flipped quite easily, and I guess that would be what I would do with either coin, use it for trade on something bigger/better or sell it outright. Any thoughts on what the 84-CC would go for? $150? Would calling it a MS-60 be reasonable?

 

I thought we only had 2 options...take the CC of course. TC

 

Cc do the cc!!!

 

You're dad is giving you a coin and you're gonna flip it? Ehh... I'm leaving this thread now.

 

He's doin' that with a 'Dad' coin? I'm leavin' too.......