I have some profit shares on 2 accounts I need to spend. I'm looking for the best value. Below are my choices, I looked up the book value of each coin (estimated) as well. I have 2,204 shares on the one account and 2,509 shares on the other account. I want to spend them all. What should I pick on each account? Thanks. Indian Head Pennies 1908 Indian Head Cent, Variety 3, Bronze Average Circulated - 1,500 shares - $1.00 estimated value 1907 Indian Head Cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Fine - 1,900 shares - $2.00 estimated value 1906 Indian Head Cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Very Good - 1,800 shares - $7.00 estimated value 1905 Indian Head Cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Average Circulated - 1,500 shares - $1.00 estimated value 1904 Indian Head Cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Good - 1,700 shares - $2.00 estimated value 1903 Indian Head Cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Average Circulated - 1,500 shares - $1.00 estimated value 1902 Indian Head Cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Average Circulated - 1,500 shares - $1.00 estimated value 1901 Indian Head Cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Good - 1,700 shares - $2.00 estimated value 1900 Indian Head Cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Average Circulated - 1,600 shares - $1.00 estimated value Lincoln Head 1935 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 200 shares - $0.05 estimated value 1937 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 200 shares - $0.05 estimated value 1939 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 200 shares - $0.05 estimated value 1940 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 200 shares - $0.03 estimated value 1944-D Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 900 shares - $0.61 estimated value 1945 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 100 shares - $0.03 estimated value 1945-S Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 2,200 shares - $0.76 estimated value 1946 Lincoln Head Cent - Very Good - 200 shares - $0.05 estimated value 1946-S Lincoln Head Cent - Very Good - 200 shares - $0.07 estimated value 1948 Lincoln Head Cent - Very Good - 200 shares - $0.05 estimated value 1949 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 100 shares - $0.03 estimated value 1954-D Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 500 shares - $0.26 estimated value 1955 Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 600 shares - $0.23 estimated value 1955-D Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 500 shares - $0.18 estimated value 1955-S Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 700 shares - $0.26 estimated value 1956 Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 400 shares - $0.12 estimated value 1956-D Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 300 shares - $0.12 estimated value 1958 Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 300 shares - $0.10 estimated value 1958-D Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 300 shares - $0.10 estimated value Liberty Head 1912 Liberty Head Nickel - Very Good - 2,200 shares - $3.20 estimated value 1908 Liberty Head Nickel - Average Circulated - 1,700 shares - $1.46 estimated value 1907 Liberty Head Nickel - Average Circulated - 1,700 shares - $1.46 estimated value 1905 Liberty Head Nickel - Average Circulated - 1,700 shares - $1.46 estimated value Buffalo Nickels 1937-D Buffalo Nickel - Average Circulated - 1,000 shares - $0.46 estimated value 1936-S Buffalo Nickel - Average Circulated - 1,000 shares - $0.46 estimated value 1936 Buffalo Nickel - Very Fine - 1,400 shares - $1.95 estimated value 1935 Buffalo Nickel - Fine - 1,200 shares - $1.04 estimated value 1930 Buffalo Nickel - Average Circulated - 1,100 shares - $0.46 estimated value 1929 Buffalo Nickel - Average Circulated - 1,000 shares - $0.46 estimated value 1927 Buffalo Nickel - Average Circulated - 1,000 shares - $0.46 estimated value
I have 2,204 shares I need to spend on my one account AND 2,509 shares I need to spend on my other account. The list above are my choices, each choice has the number of shares the item will cost me and the book value (an estimate of what the item is worth). I want to know what combination of items would be the best value? Example: 1945 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 100 - $0.03 ----------- A 1945 Lincoln Head Cent would cost me 100 of my 2,204 shares.
Well, do you have any collecting interest in those coins? I would pick the ones that you like since we're only talking a few dollars. It's not like any of them are going to be a huge investment.
OHHH They are like points and they give you a catalog to spend these points! There isn't anything that valuable on the list. I would get a Buffalo and a Liberty Head Nickel. :welcome:BTW
Get the coins that interest you most. Since they are mostly low value coins, try and get the highest grade coins that you like the best. And, welcome to CoinTalk. You'll learn a lot here.
Also, "average circulated" usually means G4 or even AG3. Since the grade listings you posted go down to Very Good, I suspect the average circulated may be well worn and may also be problem coins.
