How would you grade this Jefferson?

And I didn't say it was post mint damage. You're assuming again, putting words into my mouth.

Planchet quality is a grading criteria. Dents, left over planchet marks after striking, laminations, bad alloy mixes, all of those things affect the grade, and in a negative way. They are not to be just ignored as if they are not there when grading a coin.

 

Nope, I didn't give a grade, never intended to. My post was made for 1 reason, to get people to think for themselves. Does that scare you or something ?

And no, most do not follow my grading rules, although some do. And maybe more than you think. But then they aren't "my rules" to begin with. They are the ANA grading rules.

Like I said in the other thread, go debate with somebody else.