Buffalo Nickel vs. Walking Liberty Half Dollar

If you had to choose one or the other to collect, which would you choose, would you choose the Buffalo nickel or the Walking Liberty half dollar?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Voted for Buffs...I think this is going to be a close one...

 

Vote early & Vote often

 

I voted for the half's. Frasers design is lovely and classic but the eagle on the reverse of Weinman's design is a show stopper......

 

This one is actually close.
I guess it would be walking liberties but buff's are nice too.

 

I love the reverse of the Walking halves but overall the buffalo is one nice classical coin

 

Close call, but I would say Walking Liberty half.

 

Buffalo Nickel's all the way hands down .....

 

I voted Buffalo nickel. WLHs are beautiful, but I like nickels better and the challenge for early Buffalos is more fun for me.

 

I love both coins but went with the Walkers. The reverse is just a peach!

 

This is the toughest for me so far.

These two have always been in my top 5 coins for as long as I can remember. If I had to pick I'd probably go with the WLHs. Both have classic designs but the WLs are bigger and made of silver...

.

 

Bump

 

I love WL halves, but the only good buffs I saw belong to Dex. I vote for WL halves

 

I want to have a word with the selection committee on how the brackets got seated. There's now way these two #1 seeds should be going up against one another yet. Not with all the other contenders like the low-level mid-majors such as presidential dollars and Susan B's still in the tourny.:scratch:

 

It is double elimination.