1880 O Morgan. What does it grade?

I'd crack that one out 10x, until someone finally recognized that it is an obvious 65 if I had to do so. It is a 65--I know Morgans and apparently NGC did not know them on the day they graded that one. It is definitely reluctance to call it a condition rarity--PCGS obviously didn't want to take that risk either. Keep cracking.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

yep, keep going with it for that price difference.

 

Just read through this whole thread. I agree that this coin is a 65.

TPG's will often grade a coin lower, if there is a large bump in price, in the next grade.

 

I love when we agree. It means I learned well.

 

Do it again. God

 

Keep cracking it out.

I would also crack out some PCGS MS64 Morgans to put in with this same submission. A little prodding in the correct direction might help.

....OR....ask for a CEO regrade.

 

Looks like a 65 pl But graded a 64 due to the filled O mint mark. IMHO

 

A filled O has no bearing on the grade of the coin (which is a 65 all day). Matt is getting the shaft here, but I suspect he will have the last laugh...eventually.

 

You got robbed!!! Yours kills this one on Ebay.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1880-O-1-PCGS-CAC-MS64-Colorful-Toning-Morgan-Dollar-/190737415679?forcev4exp=true&forceRpt=true

 

Hope your right is he going to send it to regrade? But in lookin at that coin that was all I could see. Lately a friend has taken morgans out of the container and had them come back in body bags as cleaned. I have 2 Columbian expo half dollars one 1892 0ne a 93 They are much better than the ones I have seen at NGC I am sending them in for a grade to test my theroy as well. I'll post it when I get em back. I chose NGC because they grade just a tad easier.