2005 D Minnesota Quarter DDR

Hey guys take a close look at this coin i think it is a different ddr from those in the The Cherrypicker's Guide.The free-floating portion of the evergreen tree is to the right of the fourth tree as you look from left to right also the left portion of the fifth tree is sheared off by a raised spike.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I have yet to find one. Here's a Google image:

 

Here is a different google image.http://www.barking-moonbat.com/images/uploads/2005_Quarter_Error.jpg

 

404

 

forbidden link

 

Are you sure those aren't just contact marks from another coin?

 

I took some more photos the first picture is a normal MN coin and the second one is what i think is a new variety,please take a look at the left side of tree #5 and look at how the branches are gone.

 

Looks like damage.

 

I see all the branches, lust the ones on the left are shaded differently

 

I see something but can't post pics, please email me for them, and then you can post them

 

Look at the base of tree # 5 compare the two photos and notice on the second photo a small piece of tree to left and that spike at bottom of that tree this spike is not in the first photo.

 

it looks, to me at least, like a ding that extends far under the base of the tree and into the land beneath it.

 

I see it now, and have inlarged it, please send me an email at edited - do not ever post your email address unless you have a strong desire to be buried in SPAM emails for the rest of your life

Mods, please delete this in one hour

 

:devil:I am not sure if this one of 2005-D has 70+ Die varieties.
2005-P I lost count @ 97 I think.

 

this is not a doubled die , it is damage from taking a hit from something.

 

That little spot about half way down and to the left of tree #5 is a free-floating piece of evergreen from tree #5.I will try to get a close up shot,the raw 15mb jpeg file that i'm looking at is super sharp compared to downsized photos that were uploaded it shows that little spot is part of the tree.

 

If you are talking about the tiny area above the rock this looks to me to just be a ding in the coin. Unless the photos is confusing me it looks as if something sharp has hit the coin and made a depression in it and pushed up some coin metal along the right edge of the depression. If this was part of another tree from a doubled die the entire bumpy area would be solid and raised above the field of the coin. check it out and see if you can see a sunken in area at the left side of this bump.

 

Here's the photo it's not a ding it is raised.

 

This coin has a lot of dings on it i carefully looked at the dings with my loupe and that spot to the left of tree #5 that spot is raised.This coin if it is a ddr will not be worth much probably AU at best i just want to know for sure if it's a ddr or something else.

 

this is the regular


this is the op's

see the "branch" hanging down