1971-S Proof Eisenhower Grade Opinion

Whats your best guess?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

what are the scratches? die fatigue?

 

Nope.

The scratches are just that, scratches.

Guess a grade please?

 

If this is anything like your last post, I will say PR68UC

 

PR-63 CAM. Are the scratches all the way around the rim?

 

No.

Just from 2:00 o'clock to about 4:00 o'clock.

 

well, since I can't see the coin I guess I can grade it PF-69 UCAM

 

68

 

Pr-66

 

Do. I win a car, or this http://www.ebay.com/itm/1969-UNC-CA...0104499?pt=US_World_Coins&hash=item3a7a4f0e33

 

PF 68 Cameo NOT DCAM

 

I will say it graded PR69. However, I would give it a PR67. TC

 

The coin, with those scratches near the edge, for all practical purposes, should have graded Genuine 95 but since it received a PR66DCAM, I strongly suspect some "accident" during the slabbing phase.

 

Lee, are these coins that you sent off or something you aquired after the fact?

 

I submitted these raw.

BTW, the subject of this post is my Nightcrawler and as such, is extremely difficult to replace.

http://forum2.ikegroup.info/viewtopic.php?f=38&t=1080&p=4016&hilit=nightcrawler#p4016

 

HOLY CRAP LEE!!

PCGS did that damage to your NightCrawler?

 

I would hope that the submitter contacted Management about it. That is a gross mistake anyway you look at it.

Edit to add wonder if someone wiped off a fingerprint?

 

I have no idea but what I do know is that the coin would not have graded PR66DCAM with that damage.

 

Wow unbelievable..... I agree that coin with those scratches would have graded damaged. Some dough head at PCGS totally scratched your coin and was like ohhhh no what do i do now, ill just grade it a 66 and the owner will never know!