Help Grade This 1934D Peace Dollar Please!

Let me know your thoughts. I appreciate it in advance. My buddy and I cannot agree and I want to be right

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

There needs to be a "Genuine: Improperly Cleaned" option in the poll.

-Brian

 

I think it is just the way his pics turn out. Many of his brilliant mercs often look this way.
Looks to be either a high end AU or MS63

 

IMHO, it's been dipped... and not "properly".

And that's quite a spread................

-Brian

 

Still haven't been able to tell the AU Sliders from the MS coins, that's why I usually stay away from buying dollars.

 

Au58

 

not sure its in au condition, there is rim damage to go with the slight gouge on the back. the feathers are kinda worn down.

 

That's a tough one, but I'll say AU-58 to be on the safe side. There is some small rim damage, but I don't see any evidence of an improper cleaning.

 

Thank you for all your opinions. I didn't even consider the cleaning. It didn't appear to be cleaned when I bought it. Hopefully, it is just my picture

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/300750566623
Here is an MS64 that I have listed. It appears to be AU58 to me but somehow made it's way into a MS64 holder.

 

AU55 if it's not kicked out for details.