I'd say around AU53. I don't see much in the way of feathers on the eagle's chest, might just be bad lighting
The chest feathers may be kind of weak. I think it may be a little bit weakly struck though. And the chest does look flatter in the pic than it does in hand.
Going to say 62. I am not sure if the pictures are showing the coin correctly - more luster or less luster could make a difference.
AU55, because you have said no one got it, and it doesn't have the look of a 64 or up, but what do I know about morgans? I own 1, total, but hey, Ive seen lots on the forum here.