The 3rd looks better, but the 2nd set gives a better representation on how the coin really would look in hand. The 3rd shows no marks or imperfections at all and IMO isn't a true representation of what the coin actually might look like.
The second set look over exposed to me and seem to magnify the chatter marks terribly . They really aren't that bad and the coin is picking up some rim toning now so I'm gonna have to retake pics . Thanks for the input though guys !!
I hear what you are saying. I don't have a great lighting set up and it can be real frustrating to get an accurate representation of the coin you are trying to photograph. Good luck.