Morgan 1881 s. Had been bought in London this week

Yeah, yeah. You've posted where this shop is located twice now.

And it still doesn't matter. No matter how many times you post where this shop is. No matter if you wave your hands and flail around and gnash your teeth about there this shop is. No matter if you're wearing a suit and a bowler hat and cane when telling us where this shop is... It doesn't matter.

The coin shop could be located anywhere. Even if the coin shop was located in the basement of the Smithsonian in Washington, DC, that fact is irrelavent in determining authenticity of a coin. I've had "reputible dealers" sell me DIPPED coins (telling me they were MS63+) that came back body bagged by the PCGS (pre-Genuine slab era). I stopped purchasing from this "reputible" dealer long ago.


The only thing that matters and the only thing that helps people here are your pictures.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'd call that an MS64... nice example.

 

Thanks!

 

Thanks!

 

How about sending the coins out to PCGS, NGC or ANACS for authenticating?

 

I thought about it-thanks!
I think that the shipment from Tel Aviv to the United States and back to the Tel Aviv and the test coin cost
Outweigh the value of the the coin .
I'll be next year in Manhattan and Chicago and then check No. coins

 

I sent the coin through a dealer who works with NGC - We'll wait for the results:hail:

 

Returned from NGC

 

ONLY a MS61? I'd expect a 63 at least!

 

Nice coins and way to go to put the fake issue to rest

 

I will weigh in that I believe the coin in the Opie's post is authentic, but dipped.

 

I think the first pictures were not accurate for grading online so the whole debate was over nothing.