I'm wondering that myself Mark. The luster is subdued and I have just "AU+" in my grade notes for this one. I'm stink at grading Morgans.....I'm a Lincoln guy. I think I'll probably go with AU-58. Let's see what others think.
Thad, I think you got it right. Liberty's face and upper cap look to have slight wear. And I agree about the subdued luster, which serves as another clue.
AU58- Definitely hints of circ wear. Sharp details, but luster's completely muted (natural luster that is). If that's a mint-state coin, then I'm a dead horse. :dead-horse: -Brian
The wear in her hair above the forehead and the lack of luster did it for me, too............AU58. Chris