I was going through a batch if Ikes I had picked up a while ago. I think I found two 1972 type 2's. I scanned one to show you. Am I right?
Can't tell. Not well-defined enough. It's pretty obvious to tell when you've got one, though... Your coin actually looks more like it doesn't have the line, or the islands. I've a '72 like that as well, quite confusing as to what to make of it.
I may try a better scan. I looked, with a loop, and I'm pretty sure it is. I don't see any islands and I can on other 72's.
The strike also looks quite similar to the other '72 I found... hey, maybe we have a new variety! EDIT: pics incoming...
Wow these pics suck. Here's a closeup of the world and no islands. I found this coin probably 3-4 months ago and never got around to taking pics and posting about it.
I got my 72 Type 2 a while ago from a CoinTalk member! I just can't remember his name ;P How's it's hanging Merc... I found this pic a while back to help with the differences, and you might be surprised to find out there are more than 3 types of '72P's... BTW: Have you guys notice the dump in prices with IKE dollars? According to the PCGS Price guide they have droped big time! Again, this is where I get a little anti slabbing cause these guys can manipulate the prices.
Minor correction, there are only 3 types of 1972 coins. Type 1, Type 2, and Type 3. The other two earths that I provided in the above image are for a 1971-D (Type 6) and a 1971-S (Type 7) The images represent the different design varieties for the "Eagle Landing" Reverse on the Eisenhower Dollars and are sequentially assigned according to discovery, or identification, sequence. Type 4 is the first BiCentennial Reverse (typically referred to as 1976 Type 1). Type 5 is the second version of the BiCentennial Reverse (typically referred to as Type 2). All are CONECA Referenced reverses (i.e. RDV-001, RDV-002, etc.) where RDV = Reverse Design Variety. Obverse Design Varieties are numbered ODV-001 through ODV-011 and are again sequentially assigned according to discovery, or identification, sequence. For the OP's coin, it's definitely a Type 2 Reverse as the "shape" of Florida is the Type 2 Shape and is unique to that particular Reverse Design Variety. (To me, it looks like a Tornado whereas Type 1 looks like a teet. As for the price drop on the PCGS Price Guides, thats directly related to the size of the Eisenhower Market and the availability (population) of specific grades. In the past, since the series was more or less neglected, achieving an MS65 or MS66 was difficult to do since folks never really examined the coins. Today, due to a combination of high prices for high grades and more popularity with the series, more and more MS65 and MS66 coins are being submitted which creates a glut in inventory. Not many folks actually want to have more than one MS66 IKE so basically, after they get what they want, they move on. As with anything, if nobody wants it then it doesn't really matter what you charge since nobody will buy it. The reality is that the Eisenhower Series is tremendously under balanced due to the fact that the coins are not 90% silver and most folks are only interested in 90% silver coins from an intrinsic PM value. Copper-Nickel Clad coins, on the other hand, require an appreciation for coin quality. In short, your typical beat up Morgan or Peace Dollar is worth $30 (due to the silver content) whereas your typical beat up Eisenhower Dollar is worth only a dollar. That kind of "base" appreciation just doesn't encourage further collecting exploration. I say "under balanced" because the price jumps are incredible in the Eisenhower Market. A 1971-D MS66 CnClad coin, will cost between $100 and $200 but the next grade up, MS67, is going to cost you $2,000 to $3,000. Thats not very well balanced. The 40% silver coins are similar in that a 1972-S MS68 will cost between $100 and $200 whereas the MS69 will cost you $3,000 minimum. That "imbalance" is directly related to how many people have a genuine interest in the Eisenhower Dollar. If there are only 10 serious collectors but 30 coins to choose from, then the price will be relatively low. No doubt, the Eisenhower Dolar needs more collectors that appreciate the coin for what it really is. The Last of the Large Dollar coins to be made. It represents the end of a coin production era and the design, although somewhat simplistic on the Obverse, certainly does not cauyse folks to rock back on the bootheals and go o-o-o-o. However, look at enough IKE's, and an appreciation of the fact that due to the simplicity of the design, MS68 CnClad coins simply do not exist (or do they??) which generates an appreciation for the MS67's and the MS66's. I can guarantee you that finding an MS66 CnClad Eisenhower, is no easy task. But then, only Eisenhower Collectors will ever know that. Prices are a bit challenged right now but thats not to say that interest will not boom when the country starts using a dollar coin once again.
<<For the OP's coin, it's definitely a Type 2 Reverse as the "shape" of Florida is the Type 2 Shape and is unique to that particular Reverse Design Variety. (To me, it looks like a Tornado whereas Type 1 looks like a teet.>> Lee, Didn't we just discuss this coin on another forum and decided it was a type 1? From the better pictures here, I would say it is definetly a type 1 with tailfeather touchup in relief. Part of Florida and the islands are missing.
Was that your image Lee? LOL Good info, and that will teach me not to assume and read the data that accompanied it.
The OP's coin (jensenbay) is a Type 2. The one discussed on the PCGS Forum and posted here (Merc_crazy) is a Type 1. http://forums.collectors.com/messageview.cfm?catid=26&threadid=832982
<<The OP's coin (jensenbay) is a Type 2. The one discussed on the PCGS Forum and posted here (Merc_crazy) is a Type 1.>> Lee, I am fast learning that I should never question your posts. I now think the first picture is a type 2. and Merc-crazy's complete coin picture is a type 1.
